(204 E. 10th St b/t 1st & 2nd Ave)
Everytime we walk by this cute little place on a Saturday night, it's mobbed. Literally elbow to elbow. But at 5pm, it's pretty quiet. So that's when were able to enjoy a steamed vanilla custard (yum), and adult chocolate pudding (rich), and a 'smores cupcake (clever). The puddings were cheap at $3.50 and the cupcake was $2.25, but only because the 'smores flavor is considered a "deluxe" cupcake, the regular ones (like their red velvet or black & white) will only cost you $1.60!
The Verdict: cheap & chic